So, it all depends on how “natural” nudity is. As others have said, it seems normal that somebody who gets spanked when getting out of the shower, or for something like masturbating or having sex, gets spanked in their current state of undress. (When I say “normal”, I of course realize that to most people it is abnormal for adults to spank each other, but let’s get that out of the way.)

Others have mentioned enemas or dildos as things that do not belong in a spanking scene. I disagree – it’s all a question of whether it feels natural. For instance, a brat caught lying about her health in order to get out of some chores might get her temperature taken rectally prior to spanking, or get an enema to solve her fake stomach problem.

above all, do only what you feel perfectly fine with. so there wont be any regrets at any time.

that being said, i enjoy all sorts of spankings, from fully clad to fully nude scenes, although i have to admit, that i want to see marks – or red buttocks at least at the end of a spanking scene.

the storyline of punished brats is always believable and genuine. dont go off that high set standard pls.

my ideas that would allow both including full nudity and plausibility are along these lines:
- the girls decide to go skinny dipping in a lake, thereby trespassing private property. the land owner busts them and offers to either call the sheriff or deal with it the traditional way. the girls – still in he lake contemplate that having a reprimend on your judical record is far worse than a sting in the butt. one at a time they have to leave he lake, cut a switch and get their butts spanked by hand and switch. – one of my most beloved fantasies. is it hot in here or what?
- daddy/mom comes home from a tiresome work-day, and finds their daughter wasting water in the hot tub, or making mess in the shower. no need for masturbation scenes. he/she scolds her, telling her how much water and energy cost, and decides to bring the point home with a hand and bath-brush. some bubble-bath foam or soap in the right places could provide a bit of a cover in such a scene.
- the parents are away for the weekend and pixie decides it is fun to be flashing neighbours from he balcony. lift a skirt wth and without panties, open the blouse with and without a bra etc. a concerned neighbour calls them with a, iPhone, providing picture prove to pixies misbehaviour. the parents come home early upon this, confront pixie. pixie denies all, they prove her wrong and both have a spanking coming for her. not to taunt her, but to teach her a lesson that private parts are called private for reason, they make her take all clothes off before her spanking, and for all her corner time. the scene should end however with pixie being allowed to put her clothes back on, so the point of clothing vs nudity is made

i agree with everyone that such fully nude scenes should be a prk, the icing of the cake, not the cake itslf on PB

all the best – and healings still sent

TomTheDom

In fact, when i see in a preview nude scenes i don’t watch that video because i don’t like, if i want to see nude people i can go to other website but if i’m watching spanking scenes only i want to see spanking scenes without sexual contains.

Great topic for discussion tho!

And on that note: I don’t like watching fully nude videos. If a husband is spanking his wife (in a video) say, right out of the shower and the towel gets tangled and yanked off, that’s believable. But only if the girl acts appropriately startled at being exposed.

In the context of Punished Brats specifically? No. I don’t want to see it. When I think of Punished Brats I think of sassy girls getting spanked, lots of parental and school scenes. I have to agree with the person who said you have a sort of niche here, in that you offer something not found on most other sites.

I don’t think the occasional nude scene will hurt, but videos are already fake (acted out, etc. I don’t mean the reactions and all!), so keeping them going along a believable line isn’t easy – but it’s one you guys have always done well at (one implement, nothing over the top, etc)

Just my 2 c.

I think it’s a fair summary to say that, judging by the comments, your audience values authenticity over nudity; still, we’re ready to enjoy nudity when it fits the context.

For my part, I have no problems with nude spanking scenes, if it feels logical in the setting. The “Shower Girl” scene with Sarah from Punished Brats is an example of a really hot, nude scene. On the other hand, I find it really annoying to watch scenes with teachers that order schoolgirls to strip naked. That just seems constructed, and definately inappropriate. I love to see a naughty schoolgirl get a good thrashing, but seeing a teacher abuse a pupil is just disgusting. And a teacher that orders a student to strip naked has, in my opinion, crossed the line of what I regard as abuse. It also feels really unnatural to see a parent order their daughter to strip naked for a spanking. On the other hand, I’d like to see more naked outdoor spankings (nude sunbathing or skinny dipping is nice reasons to spank a naked girl), bathroom spankings (the bathtub spanking of Samantha Woodley is hot!) and shower/dressing room spankings (a gym teacher handling troublesome students in the shower would be most welcome in my book.)

Still, I often think it’s way more hot with a sexy outfit than complete nudity. Tight jeans or denim shorts, tights, pantyhose, naughty panties, hotpants or bikini bottoms are nice spanking targets, and they also add the extra dimension of the baring of the bottom after the warm up is done. It can also be really sexy when a girl is completely naked from her waist down, but still wearing a top.

But I’ve never understood the spanking over skirt thing. If I spank, I pull up the skirt immediately. It just doesn’t feel natural to keep it down if it’s supposed to be a punishment. Pants is something different, ’cause it’s after all a bigger operation to get them out of the way, and if the spanker’s mad it makes sense to just spank away without taking the time to undress the spankee. That’s a thing that I often think about with spanking videos: I’d like more realism. For me, a spanking should be a punishment. I’m not really into romantic or sexual spankings. And if it’s supposed to be a punishment, I don’t see the point in rubbing and comforting the spankee after every other spank. Once again I refer to the “Shower Girl” video from Punished Brats. It’s a no-nonsense discipline spanking. No fooling around, just a strict spanking that looks like a realistic punishment. I’d like to see more spanking videos in that vein. But that’s another discussion.

But for me a proper spanking is the 3 stager

1 over skirt and knickers
2 skirt up and spank over knickers
3 knickers down and spank bare bum

(I am brit, so panties are knickers and butt is a bum!)